Guide to the Repacks

Home

Total Value Calculated as the sum of the low values on FindMagicCards.com.  Why this and not, say, the MOTL eBay price lists or CardShark prices, you ask?  The MOTL price lists don't list every card; they are weak when it comes to commons.  The prices are misleading for low-value cards: even if a playset is sold on eBay and shipping is a low $0.99 for the auction, you need to add a theoretical $0.25 to the price of each card sold.  And, too frequently, the MOTL prices show dramatic sample errors, like when I was told for one repack that my most valuable card was a Rootwalla from Tempest, a common that is actually worth a nickel.  As for CardShark, some vendors are unreliable fly-by-night outfits (determining which are and which aren't is something people are pretty good at but Perl scripts really lousy.)  Also, the website is hard to crawl with a script.  FindMagicCards prices are prices you can pay now, at this moment, for the card from a reputable dealer.  Granted, most of the cheaper dealers don't have the range of stock that some of the more expensive dealers do, so you'll probably have to buy from multiple sellers to get your lowest price.  If there is interest in a web application that would assemble an optimized shopping list for the FindMagicCards.com site, taking shipping costs into consideration, let me know and I will think about launching one.
Satisfaction Rating A reasonably useful metric calculated as the sum of the values of all the cards worth $1 or more, added to a quarter of the value of the remaining cards + bonuses, divided by the price paid for the repack(s) (excluding shipping), times 100.  There is no theoretical upper bound for this number, but a value of 100 would be quite satisfying, and a Black Lotus in a $70 booster box repack would take the Satisfaction Rating over 1000.
Cards Worth a Pack Given that a reasonable ballpark retail price for a booster box, if you look hard enough, is $75, the price of a pack is $2.08 + 1/3 of a cent, so a card would be worth a pack if it prices out at $2.09 or more.  I frequently think of booster boxes this way when I am purchasing them